Skip to content
Scintria
ToolsGrant writerFunding
HomeLiteratureClinical trialsEvidence LabProtocol packData analysisLearnProjectsLibraryReferencesApplications
Start free
ScintriaStart free

Learn / Clinical Research Management / Conducting the trial at the site

Source documents and data integrity

13 minute read · 6-question quiz

Download this lesson as a colour Word or PDF study guide with the figures and answers. Included in paid plans; reading and quizzes stay free.Sign in

What you will learn

  • Define source data, source documents and the case report form

  • Apply the ALCOA+ principles to records

  • Correct records properly and avoid common documentation errors

Trial results are only as good as the records behind them. GCP requires that data be reliable, accurate and verifiable.

Key terms

  • Source data: the original records of clinical findings, observations and activities needed to reconstruct and evaluate the trial.
  • Source documents: the places where source data are first recorded: hospital records, clinic notes, laboratory reports, diaries, instrument printouts, pharmacy records, and electronic records.
  • Case report form (CRF): the document (paper or electronic) in which data required by the protocol are collected for each participant.
  • Source data verification (SDV): the process in which the CRA compares CRF entries with source documents.

When a CRF entry is the first place a value is recorded, the CRF itself is the source, and this should be stated in the protocol or a source data agreement.

ALCOA+

Good records follow the ALCOA principles, extended to ALCOA+.

  • Attributable: who recorded the data and when.
  • Legible: readable, permanently.
  • Contemporaneous: recorded at the time of the observation.
  • Original: the first record, or a certified copy.
  • Accurate: correct and error-free.
  • + Complete, Consistent, Enduring and Available.
AccurateContemporaneousOriginalLegibleAttributableCorrect, verifiedAccurateRecorded when observedContemporaneousFirst recordOriginalReadable, permanentLegibleWho and whenAttributable
Core ALCOA qualities of a trustworthy record.

How to correct an error

On paper, draw a single line through the entry so it stays legible, write the correct value, then initial, date and give a reason if not obvious. Never use correction fluid, erase or overwrite. In electronic systems, changes are made through an audit trail that records who, when and why.

Common documentation problems

  • Late entries without a note explaining the delay.
  • Missing signatures or dates.
  • Unexplained discrepancies between source and CRF.
  • Pre-filled or "back-filled" data.
  • Missing records of test results reviewed by the investigator.
  • Photocopies without certification when originals are needed.

Worked example: reconciling a CRF with source

A CRA at a site compares 40 CRFs with source records and finds:

  • 5 entries with different haemoglobin values between source and CRF.
  • 3 entries where the source is missing the investigator's review signature.
  • 2 entries with a visit date outside the allowed window, not reported as deviations.

The site error rate for the checked field is 5 / 40 = 12.5%, well above the 2% acceptable threshold in the monitoring plan. The CRA documents findings, trains staff, asks for corrections with audit trail, and increases the frequency of checks until errors fall.

If it is not recorded at the time, it is not reliable

Memory fades and fills gaps. Record as you go, in the source document, and sign and date.

Never fabricate or back-date

Falsifying or inventing data is scientific misconduct and can lead to regulatory action, loss of the site's ability to take part in trials, and in serious cases criminal charges.

Check yourself

Inspect one participant file. For each entry, can you say who wrote it, when, and why it changed if corrected?

Summary

  • Source data are original records; CRFs collect protocol-required data; SDV compares the two.

  • ALCOA+ describes trustworthy records: attributable, legible, contemporaneous, original, accurate, complete, consistent, enduring and available.

  • Corrections keep the original visible with initials, date and reason; electronic systems use audit trails.

  • Fabrication and back-dating are misconduct.

Check your understanding

Question 1
1

ALCOA stands for:

Question 2
2

SDV is the comparison of:

Question 3
3

The correct way to correct an error on a paper record is:

Question 4
4

Contemporaneous means recorded:

Question 5
5

5 of 40 entries differ between source and CRF. The error rate is:

Question 6
6

Back-dating a record is:

Draft study guide. Spotted an error or something unclear? Tell us at hello@scintria.com. This is educational material, not clinical or regulatory advice.

Recruitment, retention and participant visitsInvestigational product management