Skip to content
Scintria
ToolsGrant writerFunding
HomeLiteratureClinical trialsEvidence LabProtocol packData analysisLearnProjectsLibraryReferencesApplications
Start free
ScintriaStart free

Learn / Clinical Research Management / Monitoring, quality and inspection

Quality management, audits and inspections

13 minute read · 6-question quiz

Download this lesson as a colour Word or PDF study guide with the figures and answers. Included in paid plans; reading and quizzes stay free.Sign in

What you will learn

  • Distinguish quality control, quality assurance, audit and inspection

  • Describe how to prepare for and host an inspection

  • Write a corrective and preventive action (CAPA) plan

Quality in clinical research means fitness for purpose: the trial protects participants and produces reliable results. Modern GCP emphasises quality by design: building quality into the design, rather than inspecting problems out later.

Definitions

  • Quality control (QC): operational checks within the system to confirm requirements are met, such as a second person checking data entry.
  • Quality assurance (QA): planned and systematic actions to ensure the trial is performed and data are generated in compliance with GCP, such as SOPs, training and audits.
  • Audit: a systematic, independent examination of trial activities and documents to determine whether they were conducted and reported according to the protocol, SOPs, GCP and regulations. Done by QA staff who are independent of the trial team.
  • Inspection: an official review by a regulatory authority of documents, facilities, records and any other resources.

Types of audit

  • Site audit: checks conduct and documentation at a trial site.
  • System audit: checks processes such as data management or pharmacovigilance.
  • Vendor audit: checks a CRO or laboratory.
  • TMF audit: checks the trial master file.
  • For-cause audit: triggered by a suspected serious problem.
Quality controlQuality assuranceInspectionChecks within the processBy the people doing theworkExample: double data entrySystem of proceduresSOPs, training, auditsIndependent from the trialteamBy a regulatory authorityOfficial reviewCan lead to sanctions
Three layers of quality oversight.

Findings classification

  • Critical: a condition or practice that adversely affects participants' rights, safety or well-being, or data integrity (for example, fabricated data, enrolment without consent).
  • Major: a significant departure that may affect rights, safety or data (for example, unreported SAEs, repeated eligibility violations).
  • Minor: a departure unlikely to affect rights, safety or data (for example, a missing date on one log entry).

Preparing for an inspection

  • Keep all essential documents up to date and filed.
  • Know where things are and assign roles: a host, a scribe, and runners who fetch records.
  • Brief staff to be truthful and to answer the question asked.
  • Prepare a site tour of the pharmacy, laboratory and storage.
  • During the inspection, take notes, provide documents requested but do not volunteer unrelated information, and never alter records.
  • Afterwards, respond to findings in writing within the deadline with a CAPA plan.

Worked example: a CAPA plan

An audit finds that 12 of 50 participants had study blood tests done up to three days outside the allowed visit window without deviation reports.

  • Correction: report and file deviations for all 12 participants now.
  • Root cause analysis: the clinic calendar did not display the protocol windows, staff did not know the allowed range, and the visit scheduler left the window to staff memory.
  • Corrective action: add visit windows to the calendar and a pre-visit checklist, and retrain all staff by a set date.
  • Preventive action: introduce an automatic reminder that flags visits within 3 days of the end of the window, and check all other protocols for the same risk.
  • Effectiveness check: re-audit in 3 months, targeting fewer than 2% out of window.

A good CAPA fixes the immediate problem, removes the root cause and checks that the fix worked.

Fix the cause, not only the symptom

If the same problem keeps recurring, retraining alone is rarely enough. Ask why it happened until you reach a process or system cause.

Never alter records before an audit

Changing, back-dating or removing documents to look better is fraud. Honest disclosure with a corrective plan is far better than concealment.

Check yourself

Choose a recurring problem in your work. Ask 'why?' five times and write a CAPA with an effectiveness check.

Summary

  • QC checks within the process; QA is the system of procedures and independent audits; inspection is by a regulator.

  • Findings are classified as critical, major or minor.

  • Prepare for inspection with updated files, roles, honest staff briefing and no record changes.

  • A CAPA plan corrects, finds the root cause, prevents recurrence and checks effectiveness.

Check your understanding

Question 1
1

An audit differs from monitoring in that an audit is:

Question 2
2

An inspection is carried out by:

Question 3
3

A fabricated record is a:

Question 4
4

The first step of a CAPA plan after finding a problem is to:

Question 5
5

12 of 50 participants had out-of-window tests. The proportion is:

Question 6
6

During an inspection staff should:

Draft study guide. Spotted an error or something unclear? Tell us at hello@scintria.com. This is educational material, not clinical or regulatory advice.

Monitoring: visits, remote checks and risk-based approachesThe trial master file and essential documents