Learn / Epidemiology / Foundations: counting disease
Comparing populations: crude and standardised rates
14 minute read · 6-question quiz
What you will learn
Explain why crude rates can mislead when age structures differ
Carry out direct age standardisation
Distinguish direct and indirect standardisation and say when each is used
Death and disease rise steeply with age. Compare Town A, with many older residents, and Town B, with a young population. Even if the two towns have identical health and health services, Town A will have a higher crude death rate simply because it has more old people. Age here is a confounder of the comparison between places.
Standardisation removes the effect of the differing age structure so that populations can be compared fairly.
Direct standardisation, step by step
- 1
1. Get age-specific rates
For each population, calculate the rate within each age group: deaths ÷ population in that group.
- 2
2. Choose a standard population
A reference age structure, for example the WHO World Standard Population, or simply the combined population of the two places.
- 3
3. Apply the rates to the standard
Multiply each age-specific rate by the standard population's share in that age group.
- 4
4. Add up
The sum is the age-standardised rate: what the death rate would be if each population had the standard age structure.
Indirect standardisation and the SMR
Direct standardisation needs age-specific rates in each study population, which are unstable when numbers are small (a small hospital, a rare cancer). Indirect standardisation instead applies the standard population's age-specific rates to the study population's age structure, to find the number of deaths expected:
SMR = (observed deaths)/(expected deaths)
An SMR of 1.0 means the death rate equals that of the standard population; 1.3 means 30% more deaths than expected. It is common in occupational epidemiology (miners, health workers) and for comparing hospitals.
| Direct | Indirect | |
| Needs | Age-specific rates in each study population | Age structure and total deaths in the study population |
| Gives | A standardised rate | An SMR |
| Best when | Numbers are large | Numbers are small |
| Comparing | Any number of populations | Each against the standard (not directly with each other) |
Summary
Crude rates are affected by age structure; standardisation removes this confounding.
Direct standardisation applies each population's age-specific rates to one standard population.
Indirect standardisation yields the SMR = observed ÷ expected deaths.
A crude comparison can be reversed after standardisation.
Report age-specific rates and name the standard used.
Check your understanding
Draft study guide. Spotted an error or something unclear? Tell us at hello@scintria.com. This is educational material, not clinical or regulatory advice.