Learn / Epidemiology / Impact, vaccines and burden of disease
Vaccine efficacy, effectiveness and herd immunity
14 minute read · 6-question quiz
What you will learn
Calculate vaccine efficacy from a trial and distinguish it from effectiveness
Explain the basic reproduction number R0 and the herd immunity threshold
Interpret coverage, breakthrough infections and vaccine impact
Vaccine efficacy (VE)
Vaccine efficacy is the proportional reduction in disease among vaccinated people, measured in a randomised trial under ideal conditions:
VE = (R_u - R_v)/(R_u) = 1 - RR
where R_v and R_u are attack rates (or incidence) in vaccinated and unvaccinated (control) groups.
Efficacy versus effectiveness
| Efficacy | Effectiveness | |
| Setting | Randomised controlled trial, ideal conditions | Real-world use after licensing |
| Design | RCT | Cohort, case-control, test-negative design |
| Population | Selected, consented | Everyone eligible, including frail |
| Question | Can it work? | Does it work in practice? |
Effectiveness is usually a little lower because of imperfect cold chain, delays, missed doses and comorbidity. It is measured in observational studies, which must control for confounding: vaccinated people differ from unvaccinated people (more health-seeking).
The test-negative design
Among patients with symptoms who are tested, cases are test-positive and controls are test-negative. VE = 1 - OR, where OR compares vaccination odds in cases against controls. It is cheap, quick and widely used for influenza, rotavirus and COVID-19, but it requires careful selection of care-seekers.
Herd immunity and R0
The basic reproduction number R0 is the average number of secondary cases from one infectious case in a completely susceptible population. If R_0 > 1, an epidemic grows; if < 1, it dies out.
Immunisation programme indicators
- Coverage = vaccinated ÷ eligible children (DPT3, measles, BCG), from administrative data and surveys.
- Drop-out rate = (first dose − last dose) ÷ first dose; indicates access versus utilisation problems.
- Zero-dose children: those who have received no routine vaccine.
- Vaccine impact: change in disease incidence, hospital admissions and deaths after introduction.
Summary
VE = 1 − RR; it measures the proportional reduction in disease among the vaccinated.
Efficacy is measured in trials; effectiveness in real-world observational studies, including the test-negative design.
R0 above 1 means growth; the herd immunity threshold is 1 − 1/R0.
With an imperfect vaccine, required coverage = threshold ÷ VE.
Local pockets of low coverage can support outbreaks despite high national coverage.
Check your understanding
Draft study guide. Spotted an error or something unclear? Tell us at hello@scintria.com. This is educational material, not clinical or regulatory advice.