Learn / Epidemiology / Bias, confounding and causation
Selection bias and information bias
14 minute read · 6-question quiz
What you will learn
Define systematic error and distinguish bias from random error and confounding
Recognise common forms of selection bias and information bias
Show how non-differential and differential misclassification change an odds ratio
Every study estimate has two kinds of error. Random error is chance and shrinks with sample size. Systematic error (bias) is a flaw in the design, conduct or analysis that pushes the estimate in a consistent direction. Bias cannot be fixed with more participants and cannot be measured by a p-value.
Three broad families:
- Selection bias: who gets into the study, or the analysis, distorts the comparison.
- Information (measurement) bias: exposure, outcome or covariates are measured wrongly.
- Confounding: a third factor mixes up the effect (next lesson).
Selection bias
Information bias
Information bias is misclassification: people placed in the wrong exposure or outcome category.
- Non-differential misclassification: error is the same in all comparison groups (for example both cases and controls have a laboratory test with 90% specificity). For a binary exposure it usually pushes the estimate toward the null: a true association looks weaker.
- Differential misclassification: error differs by group (cases remember exposures more completely than controls). It can bias in either direction.
Common sources:
- Recall bias: mothers of children with a birth defect search their memory for exposures; mothers of healthy children do not.
- Interviewer (observer) bias: the interviewer knows who is a case and probes more.
- Social desirability bias: under-reporting of stigmatised behaviour (sex work, drug use, non-adherence).
- Detection (surveillance) bias: an exposed group is examined more carefully, so more disease is found.
- Instrument error: miscalibrated scales, poor-quality tests, inconsistent case definitions.
- 1
Ask: who is in the study?
Define the target population and compare it with those eligible, invited, agreed, completed and analysed. Each gap is a place for selection bias.
- 2
Ask: how was it measured?
Would the measurement be equally accurate in all groups? Did anyone know the hypothesis or the group?
- 3
Ask: which direction?
Predict whether the bias would push the estimate toward or away from the null, and how much.
- 4
Ask: could it explain the whole finding?
A bias that would need to be implausibly large to explain the result is a minor worry.
Summary
Bias is systematic error; random error shrinks with sample size but bias does not.
Selection bias concerns who is studied; information bias concerns how they are measured.
Non-differential misclassification of a binary exposure usually biases toward the null; differential error can go either way.
Recall, interviewer, detection and social desirability biases are common information biases.
Prevent bias in design; sensitivity analyses can explore the rest.
Check your understanding
Draft study guide. Spotted an error or something unclear? Tell us at hello@scintria.com. This is educational material, not clinical or regulatory advice.