Learn / Epidemiology / Bias, confounding and causation
From association to causation
13 minute read · 6-question quiz
What you will learn
Apply the Bradford Hill considerations to judge causality
Explain the counterfactual idea and why randomised trials are the benchmark
Describe the sufficient-component cause model and why diseases have many causes
Epidemiology works with associations but aims at causes. A cause is something whose manipulation changes the outcome. The counterfactual definition says: the effect of an exposure on a person is the difference between what happened to them and what would have happened had they not been exposed. We can never observe both, so we compare groups that are alike except for the exposure. A randomised trial does this best; observational studies try to mimic it.
Before calling an association causal, rule out the alternatives
- Chance: use confidence intervals and tests; replication.
- Bias: selection and information bias.
- Confounding: measured and unmeasured.
- Reverse causation: did the disease cause the exposure? (Low weight might be a cause or a sign of early cancer.)
The Bradford Hill considerations (1965)
Sir Austin Bradford Hill proposed nine aspects to weigh. They are not a checklist and only temporality is essential.
Temporality
The cause must come before the effect. The only essential one.
Strength
Large relative risks are less likely to be explained by confounding (smoking and lung cancer, RR about 10 or more).
Dose-response
More exposure, more disease. A gradient strengthens the case.
Consistency
Similar findings in different populations, designs and times.
Plausibility and coherence
A mechanism that makes biological sense and agrees with other knowledge.
Specificity
One cause, one effect. Weak: many causes have several effects (smoking).
Experiment
Evidence from removing the exposure (trials, policy changes, natural experiments).
Analogy
Similar causes known for similar effects (thalidomide and other teratogens).
Biological gradient and reversibility
Disease falls when exposure stops (ex-smokers).
Why diseases rarely have one cause: sufficient-component causes
Rothman's model pictures a sufficient cause as a complete 'pie' whose slices are component causes. Disease occurs when a pie is completed. A component present in every pie is necessary; most are neither necessary nor sufficient.
- Tuberculosis: Mycobacterium tuberculosis is a necessary component (no bacterium, no TB) but not sufficient: crowding, HIV, malnutrition, diabetes and smoking complete different pies.
- This explains why exposed people do not always get disease, unexposed people sometimes do, and why removing any one component of a pie prevents the cases that pie would have caused.
Summary
A cause is something whose change would alter the outcome; the counterfactual idea underlies causal inference.
Rule out chance, bias, confounding and reverse causation before inferring cause.
Hill's considerations (temporality essential) guide a judgment, not a checklist.
Diseases usually result from several component causes completing a sufficient cause.
Causal wording should match the strength of the design and evidence.
Check your understanding
Draft study guide. Spotted an error or something unclear? Tell us at hello@scintria.com. This is educational material, not clinical or regulatory advice.