Learn / Epidemiology / Evaluating interventions
Cluster, stepped-wedge and pragmatic trials
13 minute read · 6-question quiz
What you will learn
Explain when randomising groups rather than individuals is appropriate
Describe parallel cluster, stepped-wedge and cluster-crossover designs
Distinguish explanatory from pragmatic trials
Some interventions act on groups, not individuals: a community health worker programme, school feeding, water systems, mass drug administration, a clinic-level protocol. Or individual randomisation risks contamination: if neighbours in the same village are in different arms, those in the control arm may learn about the intervention. In such cases the cluster (village, school, clinic) is randomised.
Parallel-group cluster randomised trials
- Entire clusters are allocated to intervention or control.
- The analysis must respect clustering: summarise at cluster level or use mixed models/GEE.
- Sample size needs the design effect (1 + (m − 1)ρ; see biostatistics chapter 9).
- Few clusters (under about 15 per arm) can give poor balance; use restriction or stratified randomisation.
- Identification and recruitment bias: if participants are recruited after clusters know their assignment, the people enrolled may differ by arm. Prefer recruiting everyone in the cluster, or recruiting before allocation.
- Consent may be needed at cluster level (gatekeepers) and individual level.
Stepped-wedge designs
All clusters start in the control condition and cross to the intervention at randomly assigned times, until all receive it. Measurements are taken in each period. Useful when the intervention is believed to be beneficial and withholding it permanently is unacceptable, or when it can only be rolled out in stages.
Other designs
- Cluster-crossover: each cluster receives both conditions in sequence, with a washout.
- Factorial: test two or more interventions at once (A, B, A+B, neither) to examine each and their interaction.
- Adaptive: pre-planned changes (dropping arms, re-estimating sample size) based on accumulating data.
- Non-inferiority: show a new option is not worse than standard care by more than a margin.
Explanatory versus pragmatic trials
| Explanatory ('Can it work?') | Pragmatic ('Does it work in practice?') | |
| Participants | Highly selected | Typical patients |
| Setting | Specialist centre | Routine care |
| Delivery | Closely supervised | By usual staff |
| Comparator | Placebo | Usual care |
| Follow-up | Intensive | Routine records |
| Analysis | Efficacy | Effectiveness (ITT) |
The PRECIS-2 tool scores a trial on nine domains from explanatory to pragmatic. Neither is better; they answer different questions. Policy-makers need pragmatic evidence; mechanism research needs explanatory trials.
Summary
Randomise clusters when the intervention acts on groups or contamination is likely.
Cluster trials need larger samples and analysis that accounts for clustering.
Stepped-wedge trials roll out the intervention to all clusters in random order; time must be modelled.
Explanatory trials test efficacy under ideal conditions; pragmatic trials test effectiveness in routine care.
Follow the CONSORT extensions for cluster and stepped-wedge trials.
Check your understanding
Draft study guide. Spotted an error or something unclear? Tell us at hello@scintria.com. This is educational material, not clinical or regulatory advice.